Shredded rubber from waste tyres has progressively been adopted in civil engineering due to its mechanical properties, transforming it from a troublesome waste into a valuable and low-cost resource within an eco-sustainable and circular economy. Granular soils mixed with shredded rubber can be used for lightweight backfills, liquefaction mitigation, and geotechnical dynamic isolation. Most studies have focused on sand-rubber mixtures. In contrast, few studies have been conducted on gravel-rubber mixtures (GRMs), primarily involving poorly-graded gravel. Poorly-graded gravel necessitates selecting grains of specific sizes; therefore, from a practical standpoint, it is of significant interest to examine the behaviour of well-graded gravel and shredded rubber mixtures (wgGRMs). This paper deals with wgGRMs. The results of drained triaxial compression tests on wgGRMs are analysed and compared with those on GRMs. Stress-strain paths toward the critical state and energy absorption properties are evaluated. The tested wgGRMs exhibit good shear strength and remarkable energy absorption properties; thus, they can be effectively utilised in several geotechnical applications.