Conventional materials necessitate a layer-by-layer rolling or tamping process for subgrade backfill projects, which hampers their utility in confined spaces and environments where compaction is challenging. To address this issue, a self-compacting poured solidified mucky soil was prepared. To assess the suitability of this innovative material for subgrade, a suite of performance including flowability, bleeding rate, setting time, unconfined compressive strength (UCS), and deformation modulus were employed as evaluation criteria. The workability and mechanical properties of poured solidified mucky soil were compared. The durability and solidification mechanism were investigated. The results demonstrate that the 28-day UCS of poured solidified mucky soil with 20% curing agent content reaches 2.54 MPa. The increase of organic matter content is not conducive to the solidification process. When the curing temperature is 20 degrees C, the 28-day UCS of the poured solidified mucky soil with curing agent content not less than 12% is greater than 0.8 MPa. The three-dimensional network structure formed with calcium silicate hydrate, calcium aluminate hydrate, and ettringite is the main source of strength formation. The recommended mud moisture content is not exceed 85%, the curing agent content is 16%, and the curing temperature should not be lower than 20 degrees C.