The one-dimensional consolidation analysis of clays considering creep compression is a classical issue in soil mechanics and geotechnical design. The major debate lies in how to predict the consolidation settlement for a thick layer in the field using parameters obtained from a thin specimen from the laboratory. Different hypotheses have been advocated, based on which various methods and constitutive models have been developed. However, there are still some questions unaddressed and concepts inconsistently used, which may mislead engineers in the selection of methods/models and may result in settlements underestimated on a risk design side. In this paper, a state-of-the-art review and a thorough comparison study are performed on the existing methods and models for the consolidation analysis of clays exhibiting creep, from theoretical derivations to numerical simulations in comparison with soil test data. An in-depth discussion is carried out on several key issues related to the thickness effects on the time-dependent compression behaviour of clays. The arguments of Hypothesis A and Hypothesis B are revisited based on the current development of constitutive theories. Three existing elastic visco-plastic (EVP) models that consider the creep compression implicitly during the whole consolidation process can perform well in predicting the settlement of clay layers with different thicknesses, and are in line with Hypothesis B. It is concluded that using existing EVP models based on porous-media continuum mechanics is a rigorous scientific method (also called rigorous Hypothesis B method), which is superior to the old Hypothesis A method which has logic errors and may result in unsafe underestimation of settlements.

Prefabricated vertical drains (PVDs) combined with vacuum and/or surcharge loading have been widely adopted to improve the strength of soft soils. Precise consolidation analysis is the theoretical basis for the design of preloading method with PVD. Current consolidation theories for layered soils with PVD seldom consider the influence of large strain, nonlinear creep, and self-weight loading simultaneously. This paper, thus, presents a finite strain elastic visco-plastic consolidation model, called RCS-EVP, for radial consolidation of layered soils with PVD. RCS-EVP is developed based on the piecewise-linear method. It takes into account nonlinear creep with limit creep strain, variable boundary conditions, anisotropy of soil hydraulic conductivity, and variable compressibility and hydraulic conductivity during the consolidation under self-weight, time-dependent surcharge and/or vacuum loading. The performance of RCS-EVP is evaluated by comparing with the results from finite element simulations and a laboratory physical model test. The variations of settlement and pore pressure of a soft soil ground improved by vacuum preloading with PVD are estimated using RCS-EVP. The results indicate that RCS-EVP provides good estimates of long-term consolidation of layered soils with PVD under both laboratory and in-situ conditions.

It is frequently observed that the stress-strain behaviour of soft clayey soils is affected by temperature changes. Development and verification of a reliable constitutive model with consideration of variable temperature conditions are necessary. Due to the significant rheological and other nonlinear properties of clayey soils, the coupled effects of temperature, time dependency, structuration, nonlinear creep, and anisotropy should be considered in the constitutive model. In this study, a new threedimensional (3D) thermal elastic visco-plastic model is established and verified for the time-dependent stress-strain behaviour of clayey soils considering temperature changes. The model is developed based on the existing elastic visco-plastic models with the equivalent time concept, the overstress theory, and the critical state model. The thermal elastic line and virgin heating line are introduced and generalized to construct constitutive equations for both thermal elastic and thermal visco-plastic behaviour of clayey soils in general stress conditions. After establishing the 3D basic model, further refinement is introduced to consider the nonlinear creep behaviour and structuration for natural and reconstituted clayey soils. Finally, the model is successfully validated by a series of laboratory test data on different clayey soils under variable temperature paths with reasonably good accuracy.